Duke Cannon Supply Co. Premium Men's Grooming Goods

Big Ass Soap Tray vs. Standard Soap Dishes: A Comparison

Big Ass Soap Tray vs. Standard Soap Dishes: A Comparison

By Duke Cannon Supply Co. Premium Men's Grooming Goods | Published: 2026-08-01

Category: Comparisons

Compare the Big Ass Soap Tray with standard soap dishes: drainage, durability, and how each extends soap life. Find out which is best for your bathroom.

If you've ever owned a bar of soap, you know the struggle: that mushy, slimy mess that forms when it sits in a puddle of water. It's not just unpleasant—it wastes soap and shortens its life. The solution seems simple: get a soap dish. But not all soap dishes are created equal. In this comparison, we pit the Big Ass Soap Tray against standard soap dishes to see which one truly keeps your soap dry, durable, and long-lasting.

Big Ass Soap Tray
Big Ass Soap Tray

We'll examine drainage, material, design, and overall value, so you can decide which soap holder deserves a spot in your shower or by your sink. Whether you're a fan of the iconic Big Ass Brick of Soap® or just want a better way to store any bar, this guide will help you make an informed choice.

Why Soap Dishes Matter

A soap dish isn't just a place to rest your bar—it's a critical tool for maintaining soap quality. When soap sits in water, it dissolves faster, becomes gooey, and can even harbor bacteria. A good soap dish allows water to drain away and air to circulate, keeping the bar firm and extending its usable life. This is especially important for premium soaps like the Big Ass Brick of Soap® - Superior, which are crafted to last but can be ruined by poor storage.

Big Ass Brick of Soap® - Superior
Big Ass Brick of Soap® - Superior

Standard soap dishes often fail in this regard. Many are shallow and lack proper drainage, causing the soap to sit in a puddle. Others are made of materials that retain moisture, like plastic, which can exacerbate the problem. The result is a wasteful, messy experience that no man should have to endure.

  • Look for a soap holder with raised ridges or slots to allow water to escape.
  • Choose materials that dry quickly, such as wood, ceramic, or metal.

Design and Drainage: The Core Difference

The most significant difference between the Big Ass Soap Tray and standard soap dishes is drainage. The Big Ass Soap Tray features strategically placed ridges and channels that lift the soap above any water, allowing it to dry quickly. This design is specifically engineered to complement the size and shape of Duke Cannon's soap pucks, ensuring a snug fit that prevents slipping and sliding.

Standard soap dishes, on the other hand, often have a simple flat surface with minimal or no drainage. Even those with ridges may not be deep enough to keep the soap elevated, especially if the dish is too large or too small for the bar. This leads to the dreaded 'soap soup' and a shorter lifespan for your bar.

  • Big Ass Soap Tray: raised ridges, excellent water runoff, fits Duke Cannon pucks perfectly.
  • Standard dish: often flat or with minimal ridges, water can pool, soap may slide.

Material and Durability

The Big Ass Soap Tray is built from rugged, water-resistant materials that can withstand the humid environment of a shower or bathroom. It's designed to last, just like the soap it holds. In contrast, standard soap dishes come in a variety of materials—plastic, ceramic, metal—but many are prone to cracking, rusting, or warping over time. A cheap plastic dish might break after a few months, while a ceramic one could chip if dropped.

Durability matters because a soap dish is an investment. You want something that will hold up to daily use without needing replacement. The Big Ass Soap Tray is a one-time purchase that pays for itself by preserving your soap and avoiding the need for constant replacements.

  • Consider the environment: a shower with high humidity requires a rust-proof, non-porous material.
  • A heavier dish is less likely to tip over, but ensure it has non-slip feet if you place it on a wet surface.

Compatibility with Duke Cannon Soaps

Duke Cannon's soaps, like the Everlasting Puck of Soap - Buck Moon or the ThermosTM Big Ass Brick of Soap® - Backyard BBQ, are known for their substantial size. Standard soap dishes often can't accommodate these larger bars, leading to overhang and instability. The Big Ass Soap Tray is designed with these dimensions in mind, providing a perfect fit that keeps the soap secure and dry.

If you're using a standard dish, you might find that your soap doesn't sit properly, causing it to slide off or break. This is not only frustrating but also wasteful. The Big Ass Soap Tray eliminates this issue, making it the ideal companion for any Duke Cannon bar.

  • Measure your soap before buying a dish to ensure a proper fit.
  • The Big Ass Soap Tray accommodates both the standard puck and the larger brick sizes.

Value for Money: Which Saves You More?

At first glance, standard soap dishes may seem cheaper, but their lack of drainage and durability can lead to more soap waste and frequent replacements. The Big Ass Soap Tray, while possibly a higher upfront cost, helps your soap last longer, saving you money in the long run. Plus, its sturdy construction means you won't need to buy another dish for years.

Consider the cost of your soap: a premium bar like the Basic Ass Pumpkin Spice Latte - Brick of Soap deserves a holder that protects it. By investing in a quality soap tray, you're not just buying a dish—you're extending the life of your favorite grooming products.

  • Calculate how much soap you waste to a soggy dish—it adds up over time.
  • A good soap tray pays for itself within a few months of soap savings.

In the battle of Big Ass Soap Tray vs. standard soap dishes, the winner is clear. With superior drainage, durable materials, and a design that perfectly fits Duke Cannon's soaps, the Big Ass Soap Tray is the ultimate soap life extender. Upgrade your bathroom today and say goodbye to mushy, wasted soap.

Shop Related Products

Proper Cologne - Midway

Proper Cologne - Midway

$12.50 $25.00

Shop Now
Big Softy™ Shave Cream - 6 oz.

Big Softy™ Shave Cream - 6 oz.

$5.50 $11.00

Shop Now
Bloody Knuckles Hand Repair Balm - Tube

Bloody Knuckles Hand Repair Balm - Tube

$4.25 $8.50

Shop Now
Proper Cologne - Mulligan

Proper Cologne - Mulligan

$12.50 $25.00

Shop Now